Minister Backs Down on Off-The-Shelf Option for Our Submarines, Time To Keep His Promise and Build Them in South Australia

12 November 2014

Federal Labor has today welcomed the Abbott Governments back down on submarines, with its decision to rule out buying Australias Future Submarines off-the-shelf from another country.
In a speech to the Submarine Institute of Australias Biennial Conference, the Defence Minister said:

Australias next submarine will have longer range and endurance than any diesel/electric submarine currently available off the shelf. Senator David Johnston, 12 November 2014

This follows months of speculation that the Government was set to purchase the current Japanese Soryu-class submarine for our new fleet.
Expert after expert have criticised this option, saying an off-the-shelf Soryu submarine does not have the capabilities that Australia needs.[i]
This decision is something that Labor has been calling for since the option of purchasing the current Soryu submarine was first raised as a possibility, Shadow Minister for Defence Stephen Conroy said.
In fact, an off-the-shelf option for our future submarines was ruled out by Labor in government back in 2013.
It is now time for the Abbott Government to keep its pre-election promise and build Australias new submarines in Adelaide.
Expert evidence to the Senate has confirmed that Australian shipyards can build the submarines that the Navy needs, while avoiding a capability gap, and at a price that is competitive for the taxpayer, including through life costs.
Leader of the Opposition in the Senate, Senator for South Australia Penny Wong said: This is a significant win for South Australia, but the fight is not over.
We will continue our campaign until the Government keeps its promise to build 12 new submarines in Adelaide.
The Defence industry is vital for South Australian jobs and our economy.


There are no MOTS options. Even the most capable of available overseas submarines will require modification. Commander (retired) Frank Owen, Submarine Institute of Australia
A MOTS design will not suit Australia and the design will have to be heavily modified. A MOTS design even slightly modified ain't MOTS. There is no shortcut. Commodore (retired) Paul Greenfield
It is apparent therefore that SORYU would need to be heavily modified to meet the Australian requirements, particularly for long ocean transits and patrols. This would carry cost, performance and schedule risks and will amount to a new design; it will not be a Military Off The Shelf (MOTS) acquisition. Rear Admiral (retired) Peter Briggs and Commander (retired) Terrence Roach
Buying an off-the-shelf submarine with a 6,000-mile range would be worse than a waste of money; it would be an illusion. You will think you have submarine capability and the day you want to use it you will find that it cannot get there or stay there and do the job. Rear Admiral (retired) Peter Briggs
If a Soryu and a Collins left Fleet Base West near Perth together and travelled at 10 knots to Darwin, the Soryu might not actually make it or, if it did, it would be very low on fuel. Commodore (retired) Paul Greenfield